Are you ready to start your journey to a better financial future?
Personal Wealth Management / Market Analysis
Checking In on Precious Metals
Despite an idyllic backdrop, gold and silver aren’t living up to their reputations.
With the Iran war dragging on, inflation forecasts dotting headlines we follow and stocks experiencing volatility, some commentators we follow suggest it is an ideal environment to own two widely (and wrongly, in our view) touted safe havens—gold and silver.[i] And yes, both saw brief spurts earlier this year.[ii] But these assets have mostly tumbled since, which we think further disproves their safe haven status. Let us check in on them.[iii]
Commentators we follow have historically reputed gold and silver as stores of value or safe havens. We have seen many suggest their finite supply promotes stability versus inflation-prone fiat currencies. And their tangibility and historical use as money makes them a hard wealth source with allegedly lasting purchasing power. Other observers we follow claim precious metals benefit from war and uncertainty. When conflict erupts, investors supposedly run to gold and silver for refuge from related market volatility. Again, we have seen these claims for decades. But our research finds they were never really accurate, and we think this year is yet more evidence of that.
For context, rewind to 2025—a very strong year for gold and silver, which soared 54.6% and 129.7%, respectively, cruising past global stocks’ 12.8% rise that year.[iv] Both notched repeat all-time highs along the way, erasing a long fallow stretch.[v] This strength carried into early 2026: Gold and silver boomed a massive 22.2% and 59.5% from New Year’s through 28 January.[vi] Stocks, again, trailed them as the MSCI World rose just 0.3%.[vii] But these highs were short lived. Gold tumbled -12.9% in just three days.[viii] Silver fell -38.1% in under a week.[ix] Gold stormed back from here, though, jumping 16.4% to reach a new all-time high on 2 March.[x] Stocks rose just 1.9% during gold’s resurgence.[xi]
Years of observation tell us hot returns like this usually make people do two things: Search for causes and pencil in more gains. We saw many commentators doing both. Commodities’ charge followed months of publications we follow stressing US President Donald Trump’s tariffs dismantling global trade and the US dollar, rising government debt and the administration’s encroaching on US Federal Reserve (Fed) independence. Commentators we follow tied it all together. As gold and silver surged in late January, outlets we follow suggested the “Sell America” trade would boost metals further as investors ditched the dollar and US government debt.[xii] Some even pointed to monetary policy institutions’ buying gold as a sign intelligent demand favours bullion.[xiii] That demand would also push prices higher, allegedly. By month end, one major bank even projected gold reaching $7,200 (~£5,500) per ounce—implying another 66% jump in 2026 when measured in USD.[xiv] Golden bulls were seemingly everywhere.
But after their strong start and despite this seemingly idyllic backdrop, gold and silver have tanked from their early 2026 highs and are now down -9.4% and -32.4%, respectively, year to date.[xv] Global stocks are up 11.1%, whilst the broad UK bond market is down -0.9%.[xvi]
Yet the factors that allegedly favour gold and silver are in place. War broke out in Iran and continues. Spiking oil fuelled resurgent inflation speculation amongst commentators we follow.[xvii] Data centre construction kept silver’s industrial demand strong. Stock market volatility struck.[xviii] The clearest disconnect, in our view: Strait of Hormuz blockages are the chief factor driving uncertainty and energy-driven inflation chatter.[xix] Yet since the war began on 28 February, gold is down -25.5%—a golden bear market.[xx] Silver? -48.9%.[xxi] Stocks (up 7.8%) and bonds (down -3.2%) have fared substantially better over this span (albeit with volatility along the way).[xxii]
Even during stocks’ war-related dip, so-called havens didn’t work. Global stocks fell -7.1% from peak to trough after the war’s February outbreak—a fairly typical response to regional conflict, based on our research.[xxiii] But gold and silver fell more, -15.0% and -21.4%, respectively.[xxiv] Stocks have also crushed them in the rebound since.[xxv] These supposedly stable stores of value don’t seem so stable. Or very safe. Or much of a haven.
Oh, and monetary policy institutions have been net gold buyers this year.[xxvi] It hasn’t mattered. Unless you wish to argue returns would be worse if they hadn’t bought—an unprovable and odd narrative, in our view.
We reckon some will argue precious metals’ declines are triggered by rising interest rates globally.[xxvii] Since gold and silver pay no dividends, we have seen commentators suggest rising yields make them even less alluring than usual. The problem with this logic? Our research finds long-term interest rates normally rise with inflation expectations. And monetary policy institutions ordinarily hike short rates when inflation ticks higher. So how can gold hedge inflation, as the classic narrative goes, if it suffers from standard responses to inflation in other assets?
None of this is new or surprising to us. We have debunked gold-related myths many times. Heck, we even warned readers of bullion exuberance earlier this year. We aren’t saying we told you so. No one can forecast gold, in our view. But that is our point: We find precious metals, especially gold, swing almost exclusively on sentiment—impossible to time.
Absent that, we think the argument against gold and silver is simple: They are commodities. Nothing special. In our view, gold was only a store of value in the past because governments fixed the price. Since the US ended its gold peg in the early 1970s, it has boomed and busted multiple times. Gold and silver are also more volatile than stocks with lower long-term returns.[xxviii] That doesn’t strike us as an attractive portfolio addition over the long run. Plus, gold and silver hold a flimsy relationship with prices, making them poor inflation hedges. Consider: Gold was roughly flat from January 1980’s high through 2006.[xxix] 26 years! Yet consumer prices weren’t flat over this stretch. There was inflation, even if it wasn’t red-hot.[xxx] Even worse? Silver was down from 1980’s high until 2011.[xxxi]
Perhaps nothing we have said here will dissuade staunch gold and silver supporters. But, in our view, those able to brush these data aside probably have a blinding bias unlikely to serve their financial goals well. We recommend taking note.
-
[i] Source: FactSet, as of 17/11/2026. MSCI World Index return with net dividends in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 17/11/2026. Inflation refers to broadly rising prices economywide.
[ii] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 2/3/2026.
[iii] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price in GBP, 30/1/2026 – 17/11/2026.
[iv] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends, gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price, all in GBP, 31/12/2024 – 31/12/2025.
[v] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price in GBP, 31/12/2010 – 31/12/2025.
[vi] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 28/1/2026.
[vii] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 28/1/2026.
[viii] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce in GBP, 28/1/2026 – 2/2/2026.
[ix] Ibid. Silver spot price in GBP, 28/1/2026 – 5/2/2026.
[x] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce in GBP, 2/2/2026 – 2/3/2026.
[xi] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends in GBP, 2/2/2026 – 2/3/2026.
[xii] “‘This is Sell America’ — US Dollar, Treasury Prices Tumble and Gold Spikes as Globe Flees US Assets,” Alex Harring, CNBC, 20/1/2026.
[xiii] “‘The Dollar Is Losing Credibility’: Why Central Banks Are Scrambling for Gold,” Richard Partington, The Guardian, 16/1/2026.
[xiv] “UBS Raises Gold Price Target to $6,200/oz,” Staff, Global Banking & Finance Review, 30/1/2026.
[xv] Source: FactSet, as of 17/11/2026. Gold price per troy ounce and Silver spot price, 31/12/2025 – 16/11/2026.
[xvi] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends and ICE BofA Sterling Broad Market 7 – 10-year index total return in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 16/11/2026.
[xvii] Ibid. Brent crude oil spot price in USD, 31/12/2025 – 16/11/2026.
[xviii] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends in GBP, 31/12/2025 – 17/11/2026.
[xix] Source: New York Federal Reserve, as of 17/11/2026. Survey of Consumer Expectations, December 2025 – October 2026.
[xx] Source: FactSet, as of 17/11/2026. Gold spot price in GBP, 28/2/2026 – 16/11/2026. A bear market is a prolonged, fundamentally driven broad equity market decline of -20% or worse.
[xxi] Ibid. Silver spot price in GBP, 28/2/2026 – 16/11/2026.
[xxii] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends and ICE BofA Sterling Broad Market 7 – 10-year index total return in GBP, 28/2/2026 – 16/11/2026.
[xxiii] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends in GBP, 2/3/2026 – 27/3/2026.
[xxiv] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce and silver spot price in GBP, 2/3/2026 – 27/3/2026.
[xxv] Ibid. MSCI World Index return with net dividends, gold and silver price, all in GBP, 27/3/2026 – 16/11/2026.
[xxvi] Source: World Gold Council, as of 17/11/2026.
[xxvii] Source: FactSet, as of 17/11/2026. Statement based on 10-year government bond yields in the US, UK, eurozone and Japan, 31/12/2025 – 16/11/2026.
[xxviii] Ibid. Statement based on gold and silver prices and MSCI World Index returns with net dividends, all in GBP, 31/12/1974 – 16/11/2026.
[xxix] Ibid. Gold price per troy ounce in GBP, 21/1/1980 – 12/5/2006.
[xxx] Ibid. Statement based on UK monthly Consumer Prices Index including owner occupiers' housing costs (CPIH), December 1979 – December 2008.
[xxxi] Ibid. Silver spot price in GBP, 21/1/1980 – 3/6/2011.
If you would like to contact the editors responsible for this article, please click here.
*The content contained in this article represents only the opinions and viewpoints of the Fisher Investments editorial staff.
Get a weekly roundup of our market insights.
Sign up for our weekly email newsletter.

You Imagine Your Future. We Help You Get There.

Markets Are Always Changing—What Can You Do About It?
Get tips for enhancing your strategy, advice for buying and selling and see where we think the market is headed next.
