Editors’ note: MarketMinder is nonpartisan, preferring no party nor any politician. Our analysis serves solely to ascertain government actions’ potential market impact—or lack thereof.
Last Thursday, two political measures commentators we follow have been closely watching took steps forward: In America, Congress advanced a measure to raise the debt limit, whilst Ireland signed on to the US-backed global minimum corporate tax deal. Here we will bring you up to speed on these matters—and put them in broader perspective.
US Congress’s teensy debt-ceiling increase: Last Wednesday, the Republican Party’s leader in the Senate helped clear the way for Democrats to pass a standalone debt limit extension, which commentators we follow had been warning for weeks would trigger calamity. As his statement noted, he would “allow Democrats to use normal procedures to pass an emergency debt limit extension at a fixed dollar amount to cover current spending levels into December.”[i] In other words, he wouldn’t use the minority party’s statutory powers to delay a vote on a bill to raise the debt ceiling a smidge.
Legislation is now progressing to increase the debt limit by $480 billion to $28.9 trillion, passing the Senate in a 50 – 48 party-line vote Friday.[ii] A House vote is expected this week.[iii] If it passes, the US Treasury estimates it should let the government finance spending through early December. Then, America might face another standoff. If so, remember:
136 countries’ corporate tax compromise: In other news, the global minimum corporate tax we discussed in June took a step forward last week. The plan seeks to establish a 15% minimum tax rate on multinationals’ profits where they are earned, not where they are headquartered.[iv] The main problem with this scheme, in our view: Tax havens stood to undermine the initiative—including Ireland, where many multinationals have flocked, and fellow EU members Estonia and Hungary—by refusing to sign on and undercutting the global minimum rate. For months, news coverage we follow reported these nations have expressed reservations about the deal, which would see Ireland raise its headline corporate tax rate from 12.5% to 15.0%.
But Ireland and Estonia dropped their opposition Thursday after countries already party to the deal made concessions.[v] Hungary followed Friday.[vi] Ireland received assurances it can keep its 12.5% tax rate for firms with less than €750 million in annual sales and tax incentives for research and development.[vii] It also succeeded in revising the original text. Instead of it stipulating a minimum tax of “at least 15%,” it now omits “at least,” making future attempts to raise it likely very difficult.
Hungary joined after negotiators agreed to a 10-year implementation period before the tax takes effect and the ability for companies to deduct some costs, including payroll.[viii] Some other developing nations are still outstanding—Kenya, Nigeria, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.[ix] But the 136 countries that have signed on account for the vast majority of global GDP.[x]
Whilst Ireland, Estonia and Hungary coming into the fold is notable, we think there remains a long row to hoe. Countries must still pass legislation for enactment, which isn’t assured, in our view. For example, our analysis suggests the US Congress probably needs bipartisan support to give foreign governments jurisdiction to tax American companies. This means changing a treaty, and that requires a two-thirds Senate supermajority for ratification—a high hurdle, in our view, given the chamber is presently split equally on party lines.
Meanwhile, some developing countries appear disgruntled at the last-minute exemptions, which they suggest leave the agreement toothless and riddled with loopholes.[xi] Signatories are supposed to enact legislation next year for the accord to take effect in 2023.[xii] But we think that may be optimistic given lingering opposition—especially considering matters like America’s 2022 legislative elections.
For investors, even if everyone backs it, tax changes typically don’t have any pre-set market impact, according to our research—and we think the scope of this one is rather minor. It mostly just affects tax havens currently under the minimum, based on our reading of the agreement. But as Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas mentioned when she signed on, it “will not change anything for most Estonian business operators, and it will only concern subsidiaries of large multinational groups.”[xiii]
Irish economists, too, think changes will likely have only a negligible impact, which history backs up.[xiv] Ireland raised rates from 10% to 12.5% in 1997 to comply with EU rules.[xv] Based on our analysis, this did little to curb Ireland’s attractiveness to multinationals over subsequent decades. We think the same is true for the 2017 abolition of the so-called Double Irish tax arrangement, which allowed American multinationals to avoid taxes on their non-US profits.
We don’t think a 2.5 percentage point change in tax rates will affect most big multinationals’ competitiveness much. Besides, the focus on the headline 15% rate seems overstated to us. The agreement’s details could contain more holes than first appears. It remains to be seen how nations interpret the tax incentives and exceptions granted to bring tax havens in line—effective tax rates may be far lower than the proposed global minimum.
Above all, though, taxes are just one small factor for corporations, in our view. We think the economic cycle and business conditions are far larger drivers longer term. We also think the potential for slightly higher taxes, discussed for months now, is likely largely baked into equity markets already. In our view, the issue appears likely to fade into the long-term backdrop, popping up now and then as new developments—or setbacks—occur. Unless there is some big change, we think it is unlikely to have any material effect on markets.
[i] “U.S. Senate Appears Near Temporary Truce in Debt-Ceiling Standoff,” Richard Cowan and Susan Cornwell, Reuters, 6/10/2021.
[ii] “Senate Passes Short-Term Increase to the Debt Limit, House to Vote on It in Coming Days,” Thomas Franck and Christina Wilkie, CNBC, 7/10/2021.
[iii] “House to Vote Tuesday on Debt Limit Hike,” Cristina Marcos, The Hill, 7/10/2021.
[iv] “International Community Strikes a Ground-Breaking Tax Deal for the Digital Age,” Staff, OECD, 8/10/2021.
[v] “Holdouts Ireland, Estonia Agree to Global Tax Reform Deal,” Staff, Agence France-Presse, 8/10/2021.
[vi] “Hungary Agrees to Global Tax Deal, Finance Minister Says,” Staff, Reuters, 8/10/2021.
[vii] “Ireland to Join Global Pact on Corporate Tax After Winning Concessions,” Shawn Pogatchnik, Politico, 7/10/2021.
[viii] “Hungary Joins Global Minimum Corporate Tax Deal,” Staff, Hungary Today, 9/10/2021.
[ix] “Explainer-What Is the Global Minimum Tax Deal and What Will It Mean?” Leigh Thomas, Reuters, 8/10/2021. Accessed via MSN.
[xi] “Global Tax Deal Seeks to End Havens, Criticized for ‘No Teeth,’” Leigh Thomas, Reuters, 8/10/2021. Accessed via Yahoo!
[xii] “136 Countries Agree to Minimum Corporate Tax Rate After Ireland Drops Its Opposition,” Hanna Ziady and Mark Thompson, CNN, 8/10/2021.
[xiii] See note v.
[xiv] “Ireland Agrees Global Tax Deal, Sacrificing Prized Low Rate,” Padraic Halpin and Conor Humphries, Reuters, 7/10/2021. Accessed via MSN.
Investing in financial markets involves the risk of loss and there is no guarantee that all or any capital invested will be repaid. Past performance neither guarantees nor reliably indicates future performance. The value of investments and the income from them will fluctuate with world financial markets and international currency exchange rates.
This article reflects the opinions, viewpoints and commentary of Fisher Investments MarketMinder editorial staff, which is subject to change at any time without notice. Market Information is provided for illustrative and informational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes investment advice or any recommendation to buy or sell any particular security or that a particular transaction or investment strategy is suitable for any specific person.
Fisher Investments Europe Limited, trading as Fisher Investments UK, is authorised and regulated by the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA Number 191609) and is registered in England (Company Number 3850593). Fisher Investments Europe Limited has its registered office at: Level 18, One Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London, E14 5AX, United Kingdom. Investment management services are provided by Fisher Investments UK’s parent company, Fisher Asset Management, LLC, trading as Fisher Investments, which is established in the US and regulated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission.